Four reasons why VACUUM won’t remove dead rows from a table

Why vacuum?

Whenever rows in a PostgreSQL table are updated or deleted, dead rows are left behind. VACUUM gets rid of them so that the space can be reused. If a table doesn’t get vacuumed, it will get bloated, which wastes disk space and slows down sequential table scans (and – to a smaller extent – index scans).

VACUUM also takes care of freezing table rows so to avoid problems when the transaction ID counter wraps around, but that’s a different story.

Normally you don’t have to take care of all that, because the autovacuum daemon built into PostgreSQL does it for you. To find out more about enabling and disabling autovacuum, read this post.

Problems with vacuum: bloated tables

In case your tables bloat, the first thing you check is whether autovacuum processed them or not:

SELECT schemaname, relname, n_live_tup, n_dead_tup, last_autovacuum
FROM pg_stat_all_tables
ORDER BY n_dead_tup
    / (n_live_tup
       * current_setting('autovacuum_vacuum_scale_factor')::float8
          + current_setting('autovacuum_vacuum_threshold')::float8)
     DESC
LIMIT 10;

If your bloated table does not show up here, n_dead_tup is zero and last_autovacuum is NULL, you might have a problem with the statistics collector.

If the bloated table is right there on top, but last_autovacuum is NULL, you might need to configure autovacuum to be more aggressive so that it finishes the table.

But sometimes the result will look like this:

 schemaname |    relname   | n_live_tup | n_dead_tup |   last_autovacuum
------------+--------------+------------+------------+---------------------
 laurenz    | vacme        |      50000 |      50000 | 2018-02-22 13:20:16
 pg_catalog | pg_attribute |         42 |        165 |
 pg_catalog | pg_amop      |        871 |        162 |
 pg_catalog | pg_class     |          9 |         31 |
 pg_catalog | pg_type      |         17 |         27 |
 pg_catalog | pg_index     |          5 |         15 |
 pg_catalog | pg_depend    |       9162 |        471 |
 pg_catalog | pg_trigger   |          0 |         12 |
 pg_catalog | pg_proc      |        183 |         16 |
 pg_catalog | pg_shdepend  |          7 |          6 |
(10 rows)

Here autovacuum ran recently, but it didn’t free the dead tuples!

We can verify the problem by running VACUUM (VERBOSE):

test=> VACUUM (VERBOSE) vacme;
INFO:  vacuuming "laurenz.vacme"
INFO:  "vacme": found 0 removable, 100000 nonremovable row versions in
       443 out of 443 pages
DETAIL:  50000 dead row versions cannot be removed yet,
         oldest xmin: 22300
There were 0 unused item pointers.
Skipped 0 pages due to buffer pins, 0 frozen pages.
0 pages are entirely empty.
CPU: user: 0.01 s, system: 0.00 s, elapsed: 0.01 s.

Why won’t VACUUM remove the dead rows?

VACUUM only removes those row versions (also known as “tuples”) that are not needed any more. A tuple is not needed if the transaction ID of the deleting transaction (as stored in the xmax system column) is older than the oldest transaction still active in the PostgreSQL database. (Or, in the whole cluster for shared tables).

This value (22300 in the VACUUM output above) is called the “xmin horizon”.

There are three things that can hold back this xmin horizon in a PostgreSQL cluster:

1. Long-running transactions and VACUUM:

   You can find those and their xmin value with the following query:

   SELECT pid, datname, usename, state, backend_xmin, backend_xid
   FROM pg_stat_activity
   WHERE backend_xmin IS NOT NULL OR backend_xid IS NOT NULL
   ORDER BY greatest(age(backend_xmin), age(backend_xid)) DESC;
   

   You can use the pg_terminate_backend() function to terminate the database session that is blocking your VACUUM.

    

2. Abandoned replication slots and VACUUM:

   A replication slot is a data structure that keeps the PostgreSQL server from discarding information that is still needed by a standby server to catch up with the primary.

   If replication is delayed or the standby server is down, the replication slot will prevent VACUUM from deleting old rows.

   You can find all replication slots and their xmin value with this query:

   SELECT slot_name, slot_type, database, xmin
   FROM pg_replication_slots
   ORDER BY age(xmin) DESC;
   

   Use the pg_drop_replication_slot() function to drop replication slots that are no longer needed.

   Note: This can only happen with physical replication if hot_standby_feedback = on. For logical replication there is a similar hazard, but only it only affects system catalogs. Examine the column catalog_xmin in that case.

    

3. Orphaned prepared transactions and VACUUM:

   During two-phase commit, a distributed transaction is first prepared with the PREPARE statement and then committed with the COMMIT PREPARED statement.

   Once Postgres prepares a transaction, the transaction is kept “hanging around” until it Postgres commits it or aborts it. It even has to survive a server restart! Normally, transactions don’t remain in the prepared state for long, but sometimes things go wrong and the administrator has to remove a prepared transaction manually.

   You can find all prepared transactions and their xmin value with the following query:

   SELECT gid, prepared, owner, database, transaction AS xmin
   FROM pg_prepared_xacts
   ORDER BY age(transaction) DESC;
   

   Use the ROLLBACK PREPARED SQL statement to remove prepared transactions.

    

4. Standby server with hot_standby_feedback = on and VACUUM:

   Normally, the primary server in a streaming replication setup does not care about queries running on the standby server. Thus, VACUUM will happily remove dead rows which may still be needed by a long-running query on the standby, which can lead to replication conflicts. To reduce replication conflicts, you can set hot_standby_feedback = on on the standby server. Then the standby will keep the primary informed about the oldest open transaction, and VACUUM on the primary will not remove old row versions still needed on the standby.

   To find out the xmin of all standby servers, you can run the following query on the primary server:

   SELECT application_name, client_addr, backend_xmin
   FROM pg_stat_replication
   ORDER BY age(backend_xmin) DESC;
   

Read more about PostgreSQL table bloat and autocommit in my post here.